It is well accepted that the first four Scooby-Doo DTV films are mostly the best, and I agree with that. The Scooby-Doo format works best as a twenty minute episode, and many of the films feel too long, but these four feel like movies and are entertaining all the way through. The viewers near universally call Zombie Island the best, this one the second best, and Alien Invaders and Cyber Chase are debated as third and fourth best. Sadly I found this underwhelming. It is still a good film that I recommend to Scooby fans, but not as much as the other three. The main reason it is underwhelming is it uses the same basic subversions Zombie Island used making it feel like the inferior version. Still it is entertaining and I am happy to review it positively.
I am sure part of my problems are that I have incredibly little nostalgia for it. I saw it at school supply stores where I saw the last twenty minutes, and another time I saw the first twenty minutes (it is sixty-six minutes long), and not until I was in college did I see it all the way through.
It starts like Zombie Island with Mystery Inc. trying to catch a villain. This time it is in a prehistoric museum, and that makes for some good atmosphere. The two villains are tripped by a writer, Ben Ravencroft, who then captures them. Velma is a big fan of his horror novels and seems to have a crush on him. Ben offers to take them to his home in New England, Oak Haven. They arrive to discover that it is now tourist based and supposedly haunted by the ghost of Ben’s ancestor, Sarah Ravencroft.
Ben shows everyone a picture of Sarah and says she was a wonderful healer, which made the Puritans think she was a witch, and they executed her. If she was executed that probably means she actually was in the middle of a family feud. He insists she was actually a Wiccan, a good spell user… What are the writers talking about? The term “Wiccan” was not sued until the 1900s. Also it is a form of paganism, not a magic user who uses good magic.
It is also constantly said to be a bloodline, but that is false. It is a religion. I have seen many episodes and movies where the writers clearly know about the supernatural creatures used like the episode of Mystery Incorporated episode, “Aliens Among Us”, which makes this mistake worse. This is just bad. Thankfully it is some really bad writing, but it is surrounded by some good scenes. There is some filler where Scooby and Shaggy eat at a restaurant. It does not go anywhere, but it is really funny.
The plot that actually emerges is not important. Oak Haven makes a Scooby-Doo hoax to bring in tourists by making a ghost of Sarah Ravencroft. Ben is angry, Velma makes a plan after solving the mystery, and the mayor is the mastermind. The only part of real significance is they meet the Hex Girls, a Goth rock band.
They were big ensemble dark horses and reappeared in other media like two episodes of Mystery Incorporated and The Legend of the Vampire. They are a red herring, and their leader, Thorn, wishes the others “bad dreams.” That one line had my brother one hundred percent convinced they were the villains. Also, Thorn is “1/16 Wiccan on my mother’s side.” Again, Wiccan is a religion, not a bloodline. If you are 1/16 Wiccan, then I am 1/2 Catholic and 1/2 Baptist. Also by this movie’s logic having the tiniest amount of magic blood means you are able to do magic as well as anyone else, which I would think would mean most people could do it.
The plot everyone actually remembers starts in the last twenty minutes when Velma finds the book that Ben said would prove Sarah was innocent. Instead it is a spell book, which Ben takes and reveals he is a “warlock” due to being the descendant of a witch and plans to bring Sarah back to conqueror the world. He reveals Sarah was trapped in the book by the Wiccans… Wiccans did not exist then! If you use the current definition on that time then a witch is a Wiccan. This word usage is really bad. He uses the book to give himself magical powers and gives himself a mild make over.
The whole opening 3/4 of the film are really not important except setting up the ending and introducing the audience to Ben. He has been called a Stephen King expy, but I think he is more of an antithesis to Nathaniel Hawthorne. They were both from a Puritan New England village and had an evil ancestor, Sarah Ravencroft and John Hathorne. While Ben wants to be evil and powerful like his ancestor, wants her evilness, and always said she was good, Hawthorne heavily criticized his ancestor and was worried he would end up like him due to their shared genetics.
Back to the best parts of the film, and these are good. I know I have been harsh on it so far, but the climax makes the film worth it. It has a lot of stupid stuff in it, but it is awesomely stupid. Ben spends a horde of time explaining his very detailed plan with hordes of things that could go wrong; for example, Mystery Inc. could just snatch the book away while he is monologueing. Instead he uses the book’s magic to give himself super strength, fix his eyes, imprison a few townsmen (not important), tie up the Hex Girls (one is important), and give himself the ability to shoot lasers. The magic also resembles the life force entering the zombies in Zombie Island. This mages sense as the cat god and Sarah probably use the same source.
The gang take the book back, and make a big mistake. They do not use that time to start ripping pages up, and Ben takes it back summoning Sarah. He then gets to the problem of summoning a greater evil. Ben wants to rule the world and thinks Sarah will have the virtue to obey her descendant who saved her. Instead she is psychopathic, has no gratitude, wants no accomplice, and she wants to destroy everything. Worse, only a pure heart can lock her back up meaning Ben is powerless, and Sarah imprisons him. Stupidly she just leaves the book sitting there. Her powers include summoning magical attacks and turning objects into monsters. This includes trees, roots, pumpkins (picture above), and a turkey.
Best character in the film. The turkey makes an awesome climax even better. Unfortunately the solving of the climax is lacking. Velma deduces they just need Thorn to read the book to banish Sarah since she is 1/16 good magic or something, meaning she can cast the spell. They then keep passing the book in a scene that Mystery Incorporated ripped off (and did better), and Thorn banishes Sarah, but in the meantime Sarah grabs Ben and imprisons him with her, and the book is destroyed. Why did the good witches who imprisoned her four hundred years ago not destroy the book then? It removes the chances she comes back and removes evil spells. Then Thorn ruins the moment by calling herself a “Wiccan.” After that there is some mop-up action with the only significance being that the Turkey is still around and huge. Give him some spin-off shorts already.
This movie has plenty of bad. The early Scooby movies all gave the audiences real monsters. Zombie Island put Mystery Inc. in the middle of a supernatural battle between opposing monsters with incredibly complex villains. Alien Invaders had a twist on real monsters by having the real creatures be the heroes and battle the fake monsters with the fakes actually beating them. Cyber-Chase had a simple Mystery Inc. vs real monsters, but there were so many and many were nostalgic threats, but here it is the most simple case of just using real monsters with many of the same elements from Zombie Island right down to the “friend” who brought them there betraying them. It is a pale version. Also it has two plots splitting time with different witches.
A common problem with DTV films is they have too many plots working making it feel like multiple episodes edited together, but this one has a major upside, the episodic stories are food and fun to watch. I like watching them catch the fake witch and the real one. I like watching Scooby and Shaggy eat a resteraunt dry and the cook being so exhausted.
There is still a lot to like in this film. Ben is a poor man’s Lena, but he is very entertaining and quite complex. Does he legitimately like the gang or is he just using them. I think he really does like being around them. The last twenty minutes are incredibly fun to watch, and the turkey is incredible.
It is the least good of the four, but I still like it. It may be a poor man’s Zombie Island, but Zombie Island is a great film and a worse version would still be good. The film is an entertaining 66 minutes that lacks its predecessor’s drama and uniqueness, but it still has its humor and fun.